“It was all very simple
well…well, sort of. All Howard Hart had to do was to go back in time and make
sure that Mark Twain‘s literary career fizzled out. Why because Howard is the
last living descendant of an obscure novelist Brett Harte and he’s convinced
that with just a little help, Harte, and not Twain, will become wealthy and
respected, and that would leave Howard heir to a literary immortality. But
along the way Howard encounter some problems: the Civil War, the Gold Rush, and
a ravishing young lady of pleasure - to name a few. And suddenly time
traveling, just isn’t what it used to be, and neither is history.”
As someone who enjoys time
travel stories, I found Never the Twain
to a good entry in this sub-genre of science fiction. I think it does require a
working knowledge of Mark Twain and Brett Harte. I did a bit of dive on him,
because I was curious if he was real. Francis Brett Harte (1836-1902) was
editor and poet, but also an active journalist in California, serving as the
first editor of Overland Monthly from 1868 to 1871. “…his most familiar story
being "The Luck of Roaring Camp" (August 1868 Overland
Monthly), a tale with supernatural implications: an infant named
Thomas Luck seems to bring luck and moral improvement to Roaring Camp, until
his death, which is immediately followed by a deadly flash flood. With other
tales set in California,
it was assembled as “The Luck of Roaring Camp and Other Sketches” (coll 1870).
His first volume of Parodies, Condensed
Novels, and Other Papers (coll 1867), contains spoofs of supernatural fictions
by Charles Dickens
and Edward Bulwer Lytton,
plus one of Charles Reade (1814-1884), "Handsome Is as Handsome Does",
an sf tale involving Inventions
and Harte's first work of genre interest. The
Queen of the Pirate Isle (1886 chap) is a children's tale involving
quasi-fantastic events Underground.
Harte remained prolific until his death, producing the occasional ghost story
(often rationalized), though most of his later stories were Westerns.
Anyways, back to the book. I’m
not so sure what I was expecting here, though I assumed a lot of humor would be
prominent. And to some extent, there is comedy here, but more superficial. Writer
Mitchell seems more interested in the human detail of the old west (written
long before Back to the Future III and for some reason was always in the back
of my mind). So the plot is definitely not predictable,
but you get the sense almost from the start that it would turn out well for
Howard.
Still,
like all time travel stories, there are leaps of logic, mostly the idea that descendant could go mucking about in the past with not only his own ancestors
but also those of his present day ex-wife (this were BTTF III came through). It’s
science fiction, and some logic has to be flexible, but sometimes these plot holes
cannot be filled with saying “it’s time travel, why worry?”
Mitchell,
however, appeared to have done his research, as his descriptions of life in
Nevada at the beginning of the Civil War are well done and evoke a real sense
of being there. Not a great tale, but still sort of fun.