There was a lot I liked about
The Umbrella Academy, but I found myself a bit perturb by the lack
of answers to the many questions the 10-episode first season unraveled.
The performances were uniformly great, though, with Mary J.
Blige, Robert Sheehan, and young Aidan Gallagher being particular standouts for
me. The show did not reinvent the dysfunctional family trope and, at times,
sort of doubled-down on them that it became distracting. Nevertheless, there
was enough dark humor and much likeability of the main characters that one can
forgive them treading over the same themes other shows have done over the
years
.
I did find it odd that the character of Leonard, who becomes
romantically involved with Vanya, would start out creepy from his first
episode. He never comes off as the typical White Knight someone like Vanya
might need considering how her father and siblings treated her as child and
later as an adult (though those themes would be explored in later episodes),
what the viewer might expect him to be. While that upsets the apple cart of
typical storytelling metaphors, I felt it odd that this production made it so
obvious early on that Leonard had a few loose screws.
As series goes on, we the audience learn that Leonard (or
Harold Jenkins) does have a beef with The Umbrella Academy –as well as serving
jail time for killing his father, whom was physically and verbally abusing him
when he was a child- so this explains his motives. And yes, Allison seems
suspicious of Leonard early on as well, but again, the audience already knows something’s
off about the man, so Allison’s investigation into his past just seems like
some clumsy and sloppy exposition and offers no real surprises.
But the biggest issue with the show for me deals with the
lack of answers to the many questions it unfurls. Now as limited graphic novel
book series, the writers can easily plop down a lot of plot information, world
building and end it the way they did –hey, the world blows up. This gives them
a Get Out of Jail Free Card in
explaining anything, and for some people, maybe the ones who enjoy the comic
book world, are fine with this.
However, a TV viewing audience really does like some
explanations. Maybe the producers, writers, directors don’t have to answer
everything, but after 10 episodes (which may in itself be restrictive to the
creative process), nothing is really revealed, no explanations to some the most
basic issues presented here. And while the makers assume its audience are not
idiots, I did expect some explanation to what is being presented on screen.
Again, not everything needs to be explained, but…
Are we really on Earth, or is this some sort of alternate
timeline created by the seven Hargreeves adults who’ve failed again and again
to stop the destruction of the planet? Does this mean they’re stuck in some
sort of time loop (which means any of the deaths that occurred here won’t
stick, so there is that) or a variation on Groundhogs
Day, with number Five knowing more than anyone else?
And what year is it? Because it’s not 2019 as no one uses a
computer, a mobile phone, or drive a modern car. This would give credence to
idea that all of what we saw has all happened before, that Five has tried again
and again to prevent the annihilation of Earth, only each time he does,
whatever timeline they end up in, or alternate Earth for that matter, becomes
more and more corrupted and further away from ours.
As it has pointed out in the opening narration: “On one day
in 1989, 43 infants are inexplicably born to random, unconnected women who
showed no signs of pregnancy the day before.” Reginald Hargreeves adopts seven
of them, but what happened to the other thirty-six? Now this plot point does
not need real answers in season one, but I was surprised how quickly this
aspect was dropped and forgotten, so I’m curious if this will be ever addressed
as the show enters season two -as well as how these seven got their
extraordinary powers.
Other questions:
If the Commission is as powerful as they say, why are they
living in 1955 with that year’s technology?
In the finale, it appears that Reginald Hargreeves is an
alien (?), as we see in a background shot through some windows, many ships
launching from a planet. Is it the Earth or some alien world? Also, how does
Hargreeves know the world is going to an end in the first place? Was he going
to reveal this information to Klaus during their Ghost Adventures conversation when Klaus became a spirit box after
collapsing during the rave? How and why did Ben die? (this plot point was not
answered in the graphic novel, apparently either, so we may never get that
resolved) and how does Klaus channel Ben’s power in the finale?
Too many questions, too many ideas lying around like
yesterday’s cold oatmeal. Maybe we should get some of these questions answered
before they unload a steamer trunk full of more for next season.