data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6f771/6f771367bc0c188cd77c40369b5b30e1f53acbef" alt=""
While billed as the secret history
behind the First Order’s most notorious (and underutilized new character within
the movie franchise) Stormtrooper, Delilah S. Dawson’s Star Wars: Phasma seemed
designed to help fans get a better glimpse into this new character (a tactic
that Disney is now using so they don’t have to bother with characterization on
screen) who looked to be a breakout villain. But basically, what we have here
is a backstory for Phasma—but told from a third-hand retelling (which is just a
horrible way to write a tale). No one, not even the captured Rebel repeating
this information onto another high ranking Stormtrooper named Captain Cardinal,
even considers that the stories of Phasma’s upbringing are whole truths, lies,
or could be given by an unreliable narrator. So if you’re coming to this novel,
as I was, hoping to find out more about her personality or discover what makes
Phasma tick, then be prepared for disappointment because this book is
completely devoid of any kind of real characterization.
The problem with these new canon
books is that while they can often offer more clarity and motivations of these
new characters, they still need to have an interesting back story. Phasma is
still mostly a cipher here, and even the rationale of Cardinal trying to solve
a “murder” seems suspect. While the analogy that the First Order is model for
the rise of the Nazi’s, Star Wars: Phasma offers no new wrinkle here, they are
what you think they are and they have no redeemable value.
I’m unsure why Dawson took this
route with Phasma, who could’ve been more than the sum of her chrome parts we’ve
seen in both The Force Awakens and The Last Jedi. I don't have an issue media of books,
comics, and animated TV shows being used by Disney to flesh out certain character’s back story -like Phasma and probably Snoke- but I do want something more interesting, more worthy than what is
presented here.
No comments:
Post a Comment