17 June 2018

Books: Spell or High Water By Scott Meyer (2014)



"The adventures of an American hacker in Medieval England continue as Martin Banks takes his next step on the journey toward mastering his reality-altering powers and fulfilling his destiny. A month has passed since Martin helped to defeat the evil programmer Jimmy, and things couldn’t be going better. Except for his love life, that is. Feeling distant and lost, Gwen has journeyed to Atlantis, a tolerant and benevolent kingdom governed by the Sorceresses, and a place known to be a safe haven to all female time-travelers. Thankfully, Martin and Philip are invited to a summit in Atlantis for all of the leaders of the time-traveler colonies, and now Martin thinks this will be a chance to try again with Gwen. Of course, this is Martin Banks we’re talking about, so murder, mystery, and high intrigue all get in the way of a guy who just wants one more shot to get the girl."

While the second book in the Magic 2.0 series took a slower path to get going than book one, it’s still a fun, quick read. Sure, the novelty of the premise starts to wear thin as the book progresses, and we see a lot of recycled arguments, but overall, Spell of High Water lives up to the first book.

Are there problems? Yes, one major one is that after we’re Off To Be the Wizard, which had clever and strong women, the author sort of devolves them here, becoming  either cowed by men or enjoy the chase. It also takes the attitude that women can’t be friends with women without things getting petty, or drama filled. Gwen in the first book was so brilliant, yet here she continues to be dismissive of Martin (who clearly cannot take a hint) yet it appears she likes him, and is getting upset that Martin may now have finally caught on. It’s rather disturbing in many ways.

The other issue is with Jimmy, who was exiled in book one. At first I was a bit bothered because it was clear from the start that Meyer was going to get Jimmy back in the main narrative, so satisfaction of his exile is taken away. This trope is overused in science fiction and fantasy, where the bad guy is not dead (or never truly banished); I would’ve been fine with Jimmy never coming back.

But to set up book three, I guess, he needed Jimmy. But a cleverer writer may’ve succeed in bring in what appears to be the Big Bad for next installment without resorting to using Jimmy (who often reminded me of Captain Braxton from the Star Trek: Voyager two-part episode Future's End). Still, that being said, I began to enjoy the banter between him and the two Treasury Agents who are assigned to find out how Martin did what he did in Off To Be The Wizard. Agents Miller and Murphy are comic foils, idiots, yet charming. They could be a part of spin-off if Meyer’s premise gets any more thinner.

No comments: