data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2d68b/2d68b3b99b27cf1a40a70444e37fddb718242ca3" alt=""
The Remarkable Inventions of Walter Mortinson by Quinn Sosna-Spear is a
strange and unique, but also very disjointed middle school novel. I felt the
themes were a bit adult-ish, with grief and sorrow playing a major subject
matter here. We have a Walter’s mother who is in need of psychiatrist to get
over the death of her husband, but instead takes out her sorrow on Walter. It
makes some sense, but then again, I felt Sosna-Spear bit off more than she can
chew. The book as well seems marketed as story of
fun times, adventure and friendship (which was what interested me in the first
place). And while we have some adventure none of it is fun and
Walter’s relationship with Cordelia is antagonistic from the start (though we
get an explanation of that in last fifty pages of the book). There are a lot of
good ideas here, but they all come off as half-baked and some are just forgotten. And
Horace Flasterborn, the villain of the piece, reminds me a lot of Charles
F. Muntz, the explorer that Carl Fredricksen adored in the Pixar film UP.
Muntz, of course, was more interesting.
No comments:
Post a Comment