Battlestar Galactica

We’ve known for a long time that while Battlestar Galactica was an attempt to capitalize on the success of Star Wars, but it never quite achieved the intend goal and was canceled after one season of 17 original episodes (five were two-parters, equivalent to the standard 24-episodes TV season).

Creator Glen A. Larson envisioned Battlestar Galactica as a series of three made-for-TV movies, a three-hour pilot (Saga of a Star World), followed by two additional two-hour films (Lost Planet of the Gods & Gun on Ice Planet Zero). Then, if ABC wanted, he would do a one-hour series, but would need a year to assemble scripts. However, it was during the final days of production on Lost Planet of the Gods that ABC decided in a format change, asking for a full series immediately –which caught him and his production staff completely off guard. Now with no scripts beyond Gun on Ice Planet Zero, there was a rush to suddenly fill twenty-four hours of air time (and also included re-filming certain scenes in the second movie). Subsequently, this change meant several substandard “crash of the week” episodes were rushed into production. By the time some better quality scripts got into production, the show’s ratings had slid from its debut, with CBS counter-programming it with their hit series All in the Family, which was attracting 40% of the TV audience to BG’s 28%. But ABC did not help, preempting the show multiple times, frustrating the cast, crew, and the fans.

But there were other factors that led to its end beyond sliding ratings.

The pilot cost $8 million, something unheard of back in 1978. The two additional TV films (re-cut into episodic length) and rest of the season, would run $1 million an episode –again, something unheard of during the era. To help with the cost, Universal (the show’s co-production company) released a 125-minute version of the pilot in the summer of 1978 (where it did fairly well) in Canada and other overseas markets. But to keep that budget, ABC wanted a top 5 series. When the show’s ratings slipped, when cost over-runs started to add up, the bean counters saw an opportunity to blame this as reason to end the show. In April of 1979, ABC officially canceled the show, despite ending its run a respectable top 20 show. There was a huge outcry and protests outside ABC studios, but the show was done. Universal, however, was still trying to recoup the startup costs for the show and released the shortened version of the pilot in theaters in the US (in Sensurround) in May of 1979.

But soon after, ABC started to rethink their strategy with the property and after some deliberations, they finally contacted Glen A. Larson to see about reviving the series, albeit in some modified and less expensive format. Instead of continuing on from the last episode, Larson and Donald P. Bellisario would set a spin-off set some five years later, which would allow the show to weed out supporting and recurring characters deemed not essential (Colonel Tigh, Boxey, Athena, Cassiopeia) to what would be a leaner show.

“The only major characters to return from the original series would be Commander Adama, Colonel Boomer (replacing Tigh), Apollo, Starbuck, and Baltar, who was to have made atonement for betraying the Colonies to the Cylons, and was now the President of the Council of Twelve. Upon discovering a "present-day" Earth completely unable to defend itself from the Cylons, Adama decided to just head off into deep space to lead the Cylons away from the planet, but Baltar suggested using time travel technology to alter Earth's history so its technology would develop more rapidly up to a Colonial level. The Council votes this suggestion down, so Baltar steals a ship capable of time-travel and heads into Earth's past to carry out his plan anyway. After some deliberation, Starbuck and Apollo are sent after him to bring him back or at least undo his changes to history. Episodes would feature a new "Time Mission" every week, generally with Apollo at some different time in the past, and Starbuck flying back and forth between ‘Now’ and ‘Then’ to give information and support to Apollo." This was the pitch ABC approved to shoot a pilot for what became Galactica 1980.

But Dirk Benedict was not available and Richard Hatch was dubious of the spin-off, mostly due to how all the characters had changed, so he passed. It was then decided the series would take place thirty years after the end of the original series, and that Boxey would be renamed Troy and take Apollo's role, while a character named Lt. Dillon would take over the Starbuck part. Nothing is ever mentioned about the fates Colonel Tigh, Sheba, Athena, or Cassiopeia. President Baltar was also written out entirely, and Commander Xavier or Doctor Xavier was created to take up his role as the villain. After the pilot was completed, the network was unhappy with the time travel aspects of the story, which was intended to be an ongoing premise in each episode as the Colonials chased Xavier through different periods in Earth's history. They agreed to pick up the series only if the time-travel element was dropped. Larson and Bellisario reluctantly agreed, and the series instead became focused on Troy's and Dillon's attempts to protect some Colonial children on Earth. The spin-off would last only ten episodes, as almost everything that made the parent show work was removed in favor of reducing the show to Saturday morning moralistic kids show. Beyond some aspects of the three-part pilot, the only other memorable episode was The Return of Starbuck, which had returning actor Dirk Benedict playing the Lieutenant one more time and gave the character closure.

Side note: Not letting a good idea go to waste, Bellisario later returned to the original time-travel concept, and reused it as the basis of the considerably more successful Quantum Leap.

The franchise went into hibernation, though there were many attempts at reviving it, with Bryan Singer, Tom DeSanto, and even Richard Hatch coming up with ideas to continue it (all while ignoring Galactica  1980). Berkley Books released ten novels that were adaptations of episodes, along with four original tales. Richard Hatch, along with various co-writers, also released seven original novels that were, essentially, continuations from the last TV episode (and, again, ignored Galactica 1980).

 In 2002, license holder Universal Studios decided to remake the show instead doing a sequel series. 

David Eick approached Ronald D. Moore about a new four-hour miniseries for Universal. Moore developed the miniseries with Eick, writing the scripts and updating the old series, also developing a backstory that could work for a regular weekly series, should the miniseries be successful. At the same time, Moore was approached by HBO about running a new television series, Carnivàle. While Moore worked on the first year of Carnivàle, Eick ran the day-to-day production of the Battlestar Galactica miniseries in Canada. The miniseries aired in 2003 and became the highest-rated miniseries on cable that year, and the best ratings that year for any show on Sci-Fi. After Carnivàle reached the end of its first season and the Sci-Fi Channel ordered a thirteen-episode weekly series, Moore left that show to assume a full-time executive producer role on Battlestar Galactica. 

The series had a successful, but bumpy road and lasted for four seasons and seventy-six episodes. It also produced a spin-off, a 19 episode prequel series called Caprica.  

Starting in 2009 and taking up the next ten years, there was various attempts to reboot the franchise, with all of them being a continuation of the original series. But it was all fits and starts, with scripts being written and rewritten, and adding to the burden was the passing of both Glen A. Larson in 2014 and Richard Hatch in 2017. Then on September 17, 2019, NBCUniversal  announced a straight-to-series order of a reboot (but don't call it that), produced by Mr. Robot creator Sam Esmail as part of their new Peacock streaming service, set to premiere in 2020 (though due to the COVID pandemic, it might not reach the TV screen until 2021). The new show appears to be borrowing elements from both Larson's version and Moore's version, and because it's a streaming series, it will not be boxed in by conventional episode lengths.