While a slightly slower-paced tale than the first book, I still enjoyed this adventure with Ronan Boyle. Much like the first book, there is a mix of action and humor (there is plenty of fart jokes and other pubescent humor to amuse middle-school boys), but Ronan Boyle and the Swamp of Certain Death emphatically draws more heavily from the Harry Potter playbook than the first book –which can be distracting. The footnotes were great and some of Lennon’s other humor is seemly directed at adults (and I’m not sure many middle school boys and girls know who Judi Dench is) who are either reading it on their own or to their kids which was another distracting thing.
Again, actor Thomas Lennon borrows many themes from Rowling, while trying to write in the style of Douglas Adams, Terry Pratchett, and even Neil Gaiman. He succeeds most of time here, as his characters do grow –especially Ronan. I do think boys will enjoy this series more than girls, even though it contains many strong female characters (Log is wonderful creation). Who knows, really?
I assume there will be at least one more book, though we
get less of a set-up than the first book.
No comments:
Post a Comment